The Cohn–Elkies exponent and sign uncertainty

4. The universal Cohn–Elkies lower bound🔗

By the radial reduction of the preliminaries we may assume that an admissible packing function F is radial. Let a = (\widehat F(0)/F(0))^{1/d} and h(x) = F(ax). Then h(0) = \widehat h(0), and g = \widehat h - h is anti-self-Fourier, vanishes at the origin, and is nonnegative for |x| \ge 1/a. Since \int g = 0, its negative part has mass \|g\|_1/2, all of which lies in B(0,1/a). Proposition 3.1 shows that every radial Schwartz Fourier eigenfunction vanishing at the origin, of either eigenvalue, has exponentially little L^1 mass in B(0,c\sqrt d) when c < 1/\pi; the negative half-mass of g cannot fit inside this ball, forcing 1/a \ge (1/\pi - o(1))\sqrt d.

The obstruction comes from the Mellin–Fourier identity (9). Lemma 3.2 bounds a normalized Mellin transform Z on the strip |\operatorname{Im} t| \le \lambda: total L^1 mass controls the upper boundary, the functional equation controls the lower boundary, and Poisson interpolation gives \log|Z(s+i\sigma\lambda)| \le H_\sigma(s) \le H_\sigma(0), with H_\sigma(0) \le \lambda M_\sigma(\log(2\pi c^2) + J_\sigma) + O_\sigma(\log\lambda) by Lemma 3.3. The sharp constant enters through Lemma 3.4: J_\sigma \to \log(\pi/2) as \sigma \uparrow 1, so the parenthesized rate tends to \log(\pi^2c^2), negative exactly when c < 1/\pi. Lemmas 3.5 and 3.6 turn this negativity into the interior-mass estimate.

In the formalization the functions of this chapter are the structure CohnElkies.RadialEigenfunction d ς: a nonzero real radial test function g with \widehat g = \varsigma g and g(0) = 0, for a unit \varsigma of \mathbb{Z}. The chapter corresponds to the modules CohnElkies/LowerBound/*.lean; the interior bound of Lemma 3.2 is proved, as in the report, by mapping the strip onto the upper half-plane and applying the Poisson inequality for subharmonic functions (the preliminaries chapter), and the limit of Lemma 3.4 by a Frullani-type computation recorded in the final chapter, which also contains an alternative proof of the Poisson inequality for the strip by Phragmén–Lindelöf.

  1. 4.1. The Mellin-strip obstruction
  2. 4.2. The packing lower bound